Grocery Stores in Shelter Island
Summary: Here are the grocery stores in Shelter Island and some of the towns near it.
Grocery Stores in and near Shelter Island
Shelter Island, nestled between the North and South Forks of Long Island, offers a quaint, small-town atmosphere with a few local grocery options for residents and visitors. While you won't find large chain supermarkets like Wegman's, Costco, Trader Joe's, Whole Foods, or Sam's Club within a 10-mile radius, there are several specialty markets and local grocery stores that cater to the community's needs.
Shelter Island IGA
Shelter Island IGA is a locally owned independent grocery store that serves as the primary supermarket for the island's residents. It offers a variety of fresh produce, meats, dairy products, and household essentials. The store is known for its friendly service and community-oriented atmosphere.
Location: 75 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Commander Cody's
While primarily known for its seafood and prepared foods, Commander Cody's also offers a selection of grocery items. This specialty market is a go-to spot for fresh fish, meats, and locally sourced produce. It's a great place to pick up ingredients for a special meal or to enjoy some of the best seafood on the island.
Location: 41 Smith St, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Marie Eiffel Market
Marie Eiffel Market is a charming gourmet market that offers a selection of organic produce, artisanal bread, fine cheeses, and specialty food items. It's perfect for those looking for high-quality ingredients and unique food products. The market also features a cafe that serves breakfast and lunch.
Location: 184 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Schmidt's Market
Located in nearby Southold, Schmidt's Market is a family-owned grocery store that offers a wide range of products, including fresh produce, meats, and bakery items. They are known for their quality goods and also provide catering services.
Location: 120 North Rd, Southold, NY 11971
While Shelter Island may not have the big-box retailers within close proximity, the local markets provide a personalized shopping experience with a focus on quality and community. Whether you're looking for everyday groceries or specialty items, these stores offer a range of options to meet your needs.
About the Author
Betsy Burlingame is one of the founders of BlueBurbia and the Founder and President of Expat Exchange. She launched Expat Exchange in 1997 as her Master's thesis project at NYU. Prior to Expat Exchange and BlueBurbia, Betsy worked at AT&T in International
and Mass Market Marketing. She graduated from Ohio Wesleyan University
with a BA in International Business and German.
Some of Betsy's articles include 12 Best Places to Live in Portugal, 7 Best Places to Live in Panama and 12 Things to Know Before Moving to the Dominican Republic. Betsy loves to travel and spend time with her family. Connect with Betsy on LinkedIn.
New York Forum
Talk with other digital nomads and expats in New York on our New York forum - meet people, get advice and help others.
Contribute
Help others in New York by answering questions about the challenges and adventures of living in New York.
